5 Reasons Moms Should Stop Trying to Be Perfect

Hot List 8

We can do it posterI've read my fair share of parenting articles discussing perfection and the notion of "having it all," but none touched me like the recent piece called "Why Women Should Stop Trying to Be Perfect" by Barnard President Debora Spar.

Since it's a pretty long article, I took what I thought were the 5 most salient points to share with you. Hold on to your hats, mamas, because what she is saying might just change your life.

  1. Acknowledge that biology matters. As Spar notes, biology doesn't determine everything, but it does matter, especially when it comes to having babies. So while women will always be the ones physically able to have babies (sorry guys!), we can try make choices that help alleviate the tensions that having babies can cause, like staying close to family so you have a support system, or breastfeeding for less time than you might want. Those might not work for you, but her point is that we physically cannot do everything. What we can do is make conscious choices in our lives to live more healthily and happily instead of leaving it up to chance.
  2. We cannot do it alone. Getting help from men is a function of basic math, Spar says. It's not that we're not smart enough, but rather because we make up only 50 percent of the population. So if we're going to make changes, not just in the work place but in our homes as well, we need to ask for help and accept it. And by the way, there's no men bashing in this article. Spar acknowledges the increased involvement of men and fathers, as well as the challenges they face in today's parenting climate.
  3. Return to social structures from earlier decades. Remember coffee klatches and neighborhood clubs? Probably not because much of that has been poo-poo'd as time wasting nonsense in this country. But there is great value in having strong connections with neighbors and friends, as they not only provide us with support, but they can be a wonderful resource when we need help. I'm a firm believer that our tendency toward solo achievement and perfection, particularly in our society, is slowly killing mothers. Or at least, killing any hope of true happiness.
  4. Recognize that the quest for perfection is a myth. If we continue to use perfection as a standard for success, Spar states that we're condemning ourselves and our daughters to failure. And really, she's got a point. So much of what many women are dissatisfied with in their lives has to do with feeling not good enough. And if we ditch the image of "the perfect mother" from our heads, the only goal we have left is to just do what's best for our children and ourselves.
  5. Channel the passion of political foremothers. "Feminism wasn't supposed to make us miserable," according to Spar, and she's right. Her suggestions for making change aren't elaborate or even that time consuming, but they could make a world of difference. How about starting a small babysitting co-op in your neighborhood to help frazzled moms? Or host monthly potluck dinners like our grandparents used to do back in the day?

By making small changes, by giving ourselves a break and realizing that we're all in this together, we might just enjoy our lives a little more. And we might just give our daughters a fighting chance at happiness too.

What do you think about Spar's points about women and perfection?

Photo via DonkeyHotey/Flickr

feminism, childcare


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Flori... Floridamom96

Great article! The Stir needs more of these.

Pinkmani Pinkmani

I've never met a mother that was trying to be perfect. I think the "perfection" that is being referred to is the fact that she wants to set her kids up for success, to have a better life than she did, to be people with good character, and to be happy and comfortable with who they are. 

Anna Potts

how dare you use Rosie the Riveter. and then say that we as women cant do it alone! maybe you cant raise a family and make a home on your own thats your deal, i have a man he pays the bills and loves us, his mom raised him and his brother while working 3 jobs and to hear her talk about every thing she did on her own is an insperation. but to hear this bull that we cant  do it alone, bless your sad little life. maybe  we are not perfect but when you stop striving to be the best women you can be thats when you lose.

zandh... zandhmom2

Anna, I don't think this article is saying a women CAN'T do it all but instead saying that we SHOULDN'T have to do it all alone. Many great women have raised great children on their own, my mom included but it is definitely easier to do it with help and support from others.

Thank you for a great article.

jpfsmom jpfsmom

Well stated and I agree more articles like this are needed on The Stir. And Anna kudos to you if you are able to raise your family without a single ounce of help but your anger laced reaction is I strive not to sound at the end of the day, so I'll take some help if needed or offered :). I'd rather be happy and relieved than alone, angry and perfect.

Tasha Elsnau

 Anna Potts, I'm sorry but the woman is working 3 jobs, no way is she doing it alone. There is a babysitter in there somewhere taking some of the load off. There is other help out there as well i.e. schools, teachers, etc.

wamom223 wamom223

I really liked this article and agree with the commenter's above that the stir could use more blogs like this.  I will admit after waiting so long to be a mom I wanted to do everything right and be perfect.  I had a plan and no one was going to stop me.  Then my son was born and I found out its great to have a plan but its better to be able to roll with the punches.  I feel like I'm a great mom (not perfect at all) only because of my support system.  I am the primary parent since I don't work, but that doesn't mean I don't get a ton of help with our son and around the house. All my friends are jealous that I got a man that does the laundry, and cooks half the meals.  I respect single mom's but no one can make it alone.   

1-8 of 8 comments