New Hope for Women With Postpartum Depression


womens mood disordersPostpartum depression is the most horribly ironic illness known to womankind. Here you are, supposed to be on top of the world, and the best moment of your life is made a wretched hell by rampant hormones at war with your brain. If depression is a b-word, then postpartum depression is a c-word, and postpartum psychosis -- a separate, severe, life-threatening illness – well, there’s just no word bad enough.
The Perinatal Psychiatry Inpatient Unit opened on August 15 at the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill. The first of its kind, it’s a place that specializes in the unique struggles of postpartum mood disorders. When a woman feels that she is in danger of hurting herself or her child, she now has someplace to check in where the medical professionals know what is happening to her, and how to stop it.
To which I say: Great. And it took how long?!

Doctors have known about postpartum mood disorders for hundreds of years, and 29 countries – including Canada, the UK, Australia and Italy, but not including the U.S. – have a special legal distinction for women who kill their babies, so that if a woman is convicted of infanticide, she is given treatment for mental illness. In a comprehensive 2004 article published in the American Journal of Psychiatry, Margaret G. Spinelli, M.D. outlined the history of postpartum mental illnesses and called them “predictable, identifiable, treatable, and, therefore, preventable.” The differences between baby blues, postpartum depression, and postpartum psychosis should be required reading for any mom-to-be.
Spinelli's 2002 textbook, Infanticide: Psychosocial and Legal Perspectives on Mothers Who Kill ($83 at Amazon), came out almost at the same time as the Andrea Yates case – in 2001. After suffering repeatedly from post-partum psychosis and being warned not to have any more kids, Yates drowned all five of her children in a bathtub, including her 6-month-old baby. Her husband, Rusty Yates, now says he ignored obvious signs that she needed more help than he could give, and that he bungled the whole deal. Yeah. No kidding. Yates' case brought national attention to the plight of the mentally ill and those that can be harmed if they aren't treated properly; a life sentence was eventually overturned, and Yates now resides in a mental hospital.
Despite the attention, the stigma against women who suffer from postpartum depression or psychosis continues. Tom Cruise famously mocked Brooke Shields for speaking out about her struggle with PPD and her decision to take antidepressants. Many women are afraid to get help because their support system – their families, even their husbands, who are supposed to have their backs no matter what – minimize their pain and fear. The worse the illness gets, the more the woman thinks that if she treats it, she’ll lose her kids and be treated like a criminal.
And she’s often right. The woman in a recent radio story about the clinic described how she told her midwife she was having thoughts of hurting herself and her baby, and was placed in a nightmarish psychiatric facility in the “same ward that houses schizophrenics, drug addicts, and dementia patients.” Her doctors didn’t understand how PPD is different from other mental illnesses, and their treatment of her didn’t take her recent childbirth into account — though she was allowed to pump, at least.
The new unit, in contrast, offers time with the baby and the woman’s partner, lactation consultation and new-baby care, in addition to the same psychiatric assessments and cautions that a regular mental-health facility would provide. The hospital already has a well-regarded center for women’s mood disorders, so the right professionals were in place already.
But this doesn’t change the stigma, and it doesn’t change the legal system, and I think there are only five beds in this facility. Of course, there are clinics and professionals that specialize in postpartum mood disorders – they can be found at Postpartum Support International. But this one little overnight clinic had better be just the beginning of a slew of similar places. One is just not enough.
Do you think we should have had an in-patient clinic for women suffering from postpartum mental illnesses a long time ago?

Image via

postpartum recovery, emotional health


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

Steph... Stephenni

This is great. I wish all states offered a place like this for mothers. With my first baby I was completely fine but with baby #2 I was a mess and had NO idea what was going on with me since I had not experienced it with baby #1. It was a frustrating road until I finally figured out what was going on. Luckily my husband and family were very supportive.

nonmember avatar phareDraw

Good day I am so delighted I found your web site, I really found you by error, while I was browsing on Askjeeve for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and would just like to say many thanks for a marvelous post and a all round entertaining blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to go through it all at the minute but I have saved it and also added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read much more, Please do keep up the superb job.

steff... steffielynne

oh god this  is so exciting. i hope other hospitals do this...i struggled witf PPD horibly and would have loved this

Racer15 Racer15

Oh yes, yes, yes! I am a nursing student, currently studying behavioral health. I also had a grandmother that died because her doctors did not understand how to handle her PPD. There is so much stigma attatched to mental illness and it makes me sad. Mental illness is the same as any other kind of sickness! The only difference is that it involves your brain, and that in turn alters your perception of the world. Mentally ill patients cannot help their sickness, they can't will themselves well, they are generally NOT dangerous, they need empathy, they need kindness, patience, and understanding. Because of the sad fate my grandmother met, and because of the history of mental illness within my own family (I suffer from clincial depression and GAD), I would very much love to eventually specialize in Postpartum mental illnesses. In this day and age. no woman should ever have to feel lost and alone due to mental illness. Really, NO ONE should feel ashamed to admit that they have a mental illness, they should feel pride that they can admit that they have a PHYSIOLOGICAL problem that just happens to effect the brain, and seek help. There are many many resources available, and many nonjudgemental people, like me, waiting to help :)

Kathy Morelli

thanks for this post about perinatal mood disorders. It's a great thing to raise awareness about PMD. I would have to answer yes to your question! In the UK, mother-baby units are the norm.  the idea that the childbearing year is a very special year and a time when women and their relationship with their babies should be sheltered is a very old idea.... I guess in Europe they never un-embraced this idea. I'm happy that we are now opening the door to mother baby units here in the US.

It's true there are practitioners  Across the US specializing in Maternal Mental Health (or the emotions of pregnancy and birth). I have been a member of Postpartum Support International for many years.

You can find me in the PSI directory and on psychology today,

thanks, and take care, Kathy



Torto... Tortoise77

I think this is great! Many women need serious help. Also there should be education classes just how there is birthing classes and breastfeeding classes. If we help women while they are pregnant and offer them support and teach them ways to identify PPD/A/P  many of these new moms would get the help they need and not be afraid of it. It is hard to come out and yell for help when you are depressed. I hope that soon clinics like these spread! I never suffered from severe PPD but I did have a very traumatic birth but with the support of my family and husband I got through it. I thank my family for their support everyday and for other women to have access to  the same support is wonderful.  

nonmember avatar MenInance

You are mistaken. I can defend the position.

[url=]Faire un site internet[/url]

nonmember avatar greemoAgend

These are all fairy tales!

nonmember avatar ZowBiowswrozy

Also what from this follows?

nonmember avatar LiCemirmDum

It is possible to tell, this :) exception to the rules

1-10 of 12 comments 12 Last