I have a confession to make, and I'm sure it's going to piss some of you right the hell off: I'm not sure I believe in colic.
Okay, OKAY, hold up, let me explain: what I mean is, I'm not sure I believe that every single baby that's described as having colic or reflux — or who's being actively treated with medications to improve their incessant crying/screaming/general horribleness — really is suffering from a medical ailment other than being a Tiny Baby Who Is Also Kind of an Asshole.
It's just ... I kind of think that parents these days feel like they need to diagnose everything. They want a reason for why things suck so much, and sometimes the real reason something sucks is that it's a sucky situation, full stop. Newborns are magical wonderful innocent souls who SUCK a WHOLE LOT, what with the crying and the inexplicable screaming and the spitting up and the not knowing how to sleep and the whole thing where they're tiny forming human blobs whose various parts don't quite work perfectly yet (hello, floppy esophageal sphincter and misfiring brain synapses).
Look, I'm not saying it's never GER. I'm just saying ... how is it that nearly every new mom I know has their baby on Zantac? Doesn't that seem a little ... odd? Everyone's so freaked out about their crying kid, and, hey, believe me, I get it. But man, new parents are under enough pressure without having the burden of figuring out how to Make Things Better with the right doctor or wedge-shaped pillow or special sling or whatever it is — wouldn't it be easier if doctors would just say, "Dude, this totally blows, but in a couple months, it'll be like you have a new kid"?
The further I get from my own baby-raising years, the more Andy-Rooney-ish I feel about certain baby-care topics. It seems like there's just so much pressure to make all the right choices and be so incredibly informed and do things Exactly the Right Way, like you're not even allowed to just sit back and wallow in your own ineptitude EVER. Like, you can't even feel like shit after your baby is born without wondering if you should be under the appropriate psychiatric care for postpartum depression. How is anyone NOT depressed after being physically ravaged during birth, the hormonal maelstrom afterwards, and being instantly thrown into the boot-camp-esque conditions of caring for a newborn? The only pill I could have taken to make that better would have been if a full-time nanny could be crammed in a gel cap.
I'm not saying we shouldn't figure out how to improve a bad situation where we can, but I think parents should also feel like it's okay to just sit back and say, god, this is the WORST. Then muscle through the day, because that's what we do. Being constantly told there's a way to make it all better — if only we advocate for our child hard enough, if only we listen to the right advice — well, things are hard enough in those early months. Wouldn't it be more of a relief to know we're already doing the best that we can?
Do you think there's too much pressure on parents to "fix" common baby-care challenges these days?
Code for 'That's an Ugly Baby!'
5 Fun, Fruity Summer Drinks
Dad Blogs About Moms' Irrational Fears
Girl Ravaged by Flesh-Eating Bacteria Shouldn't Worry You
Pro Athlete Takes Jilted Teen to the Prom (VIDEO)
100 Most Popular Baby Names of the Year
Punch Up Your Pasta With These Fun Ingredients
3-Year-Old Gets Her Groove On to Gotye (VIDEO)
Should Texting While Walking be a Crime? (VIDEO)
Newsweek's 'Gay President' Cover
5 Women Who Took 'Beauty' Too Far (PHOTOS)
Fabulous Chocolate Peanut Butter Crisp Bars
Sensational Summer Soup Recipes
11 Moms You'll Meet at the Playground
Facebook Snooping by Nosy Bosses
Go Backstage with a Broadway Star!
Time Magazine Cover Gets Moms Fired Up!
Explaining Sex to Kids...And Other...
Cameron Diaz Talks Circumcision!

Comments (40)
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!! You took the words I would love to say at some of our moms right out of my mouth!
Babies cry! Babies spit up! Babies sleep at weird times and for weird amounts of time! They also dont poop every single day. (Moms seem WAY concerned with the poop in my office!) Somewhere along the way people seem to have forgotten these things and insist on a diagnosis and medication for everything!!
I actually believe the opposite, especially now that they are pushing this "Period of Purple Crying" and telling parents that babies scream for hours on end for no reason. I think that is a disservice to babies, and that parents who just accept that and don't seek to find IF there is a cause are not doing right by their child. I DON'T think that babies scream for no reason. My scientific background tells me that there should be a reason. Maybe doctors can't find the reason, but there's gotta be one for MOST babies.
I think that just accepting that your baby is a screamer is almost like child abuse- what if that child really IS in pain, but you just chalk it up to "eh, babies scream. I am doing a fine job as a parent"? That poor kid! At least make an EFFORT to find out if there's a reason, and ADVOCATE for your child!
I don't know why anyone would not want to "fix" reflux in your baby. Having them lose weight and possibly die is not worth trying to tough it out, imo. Most people do not have medical degrees and do not know what is "common baby-care challenges" is.
I think you're right - to a degree. There are some things that are just part of being an infant and all we as parents can do is ride it out. Sometimes it's severe enough to warrant treatment, so we should definitely ask our pediatricians and do our research, but not everything needs a pill.
Ok, I partially agree with you...here is why:
I have a 10 month old baby, for the first 3 months of her life she cried all the time...I mean ALL THE TIME!
It scared me when she would scream for hours and nothing would seem to calm her down. I would take her in the middle of the night to the doctor only for them to tell me she has "COLIC" and she will grown out of it in time...There was nothing they can do about it...
I DON'T believe in COLIC!!!
I was determined to find help for my baby, if she was in pain I wanted to help her because she cannot say what she was feeling. As a parent we are there to protect and help our kids...it was my place to help her.
I researched, took her to different doctors until she was finally placed on zantac for reflux because she stop eating. I do not regret that she was put on medication because it helped her and she was not fussy, crying, and she resumed eating.
She is not 10 months old and she is the happiest baby u can find and SMART!
i totally agree! We thought my daughter had Reflux or colic. turns out that A) our kid was a SERIOUSLY huge eater and B) she was allergic to Enfamil. took about 4 months to finally, FINALLY determine that. she wasn't even lactose intolerant, like we also thought. She was on soy formula until she was about 5-6 months old and it wasn't even necessary. Babies are just kind of... jerks! they don't mean to be, they can't help it, they just don't know any other way to communicate than to scream and cry. and it is so frustrating but it's not a medical condition. it's just their state of being. unfortunately, this isn't something that's talked about enough--people, when they want you to have kids for their own reasons, only tell you the good things and don't bother preparing you for the parts that are hard. My little girl is now 16 months old and absolutely precious and wonderful.... but i don't know that i could go through those early months again. It was so scary and incredibly rough!!
I agree with the article. My DD cried from 7pm to 5am every night until she was about 3 months old. there was nothing wrong with her. She didnt have reflux and rarely even spit up. She ate fine and had plenty of diapers for me. She was never diagnosed with anything and eventually just grew out of it. She is now a healthy, fun 2.5yo.
i agree with you, to a point. in instances where there's a serious medical condition DO need to be treated... but there's a difference between a baby who is just crying and a baby who cries incessantly or because something is wrong.
my niece cried a LOT during her first 2 months. we thought colic too, but she also *HAD* to be with my SIL *ALL* the time... my sil ended up buying a front sling just so she could still take care of her other 3 children! fast forward to the 3 month checkup, and it turns out they discover she's a "lazy eater". i had NEVER heard of this before in my life, and i felt like - seriously? is this even a THING?!? and i can tell you, it is. she would get ready to nurse and then be too comfortable to suckle, and fall asleep without eating. so she was constantly hungry, but wouldn't eat. they switched her to formula (please seriously - i don't want to hear about bf'ing vs formula - NOT the point here) and she's done a complete 180!! we joke that my SIL got a brand new baby...
so yeah, i see both sides... but when it's ongoing with no answer, yeah you do tend to look for an answer, even if the obvious one is too - - well, obvious. lol