Breast Milk Can Be Lifesaving But We're Making the Wrong Decisions


breastfeedingI’ve just read an article that shocked me. There are babies suffering and dying because they don’t get enough to eat, yet the best nutrition for them is inches away at all times.

Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times visited the African countries of Niger, Burkina Faso, Senegal, and Mauritania, and found there were rampant misunderstandings about babies’ needs that are causing 1.4 million child deaths every year.

I’m embarrassed to admit this, but I really did naively expect that one of the silver linings of living in a third-world country would be that you’d be in better contact with nature, and therefore have a smarter attitude toward things like breastfeeding. Surprise, surprise, we’re all equally capable of making flawed decisions.

According to the article, some of the wisdom that has been passed down in rural African villages include waiting 'til the mature milk has come in to nurse a newborn (in other words, skipping the colostrum entirely), supplementing breastfeeding with well or puddle water up to five times a day, and creating a liquid by washing verses of the Koran off a board and feeding that to a baby to give him protection. (No weirder than a baptism or a briss, really, but in conjunction with everything else, perhaps not be the best idea.) These women really think they are doing the best for their babies by withholding precious early milk and giving them possibly contaminated water, and it’s costing them lives.

It’s so odd, because when my mom chose to breastfeed her first baby in 1958, she was literally called a savage. “You don’t know what’s in breast milk,” she was told. “You live in a civilized nation, where the formula has reliable ingredients, and you can be sure your baby is getting enough because you measure it yourself.” My anxious, young mom, at 21, would weigh her infant daughter before and after every feed because she worried about going against the “wisdom” of almost everyone around her. Her own mom had chosen not to breastfeed her because she had reflux, and the “wisdom” of her time said it was the mom’s milk’s fault. How do we get so much crappy wisdom?

I checked in with Emma Kwansica, a breastfeeding advocate who started a milk-sharing site called Human Milk for Human Babies that now covers 54 countries and has Facebook pages for every state and province in the US and Canada. She’s a well-educated breastfeeding advocate. Why, I asked her, did women get these kooky ideas about their breasts not being for their babies?

“Nobody’s immune to this sort of thing,” she told me. “There’s that old story about the family where they cut off the end of the roast before putting it in the pan ‘because that’s how Grandma did it,’ and it turns out Grandma only did that because she had a crappy little pan and that’s the only way she could fit the roast in. Traditions, whether they’re religious, cultural, or just superstitious, are powerful. If everyone around you believes something, it’s easy to perpetuate a myth, and even easier if you don’t have access to information and education.”

In Haiti, she says, women were told not to breastfeed after the earthquake because their sorrow would go through the milk into their babies. But I had to ask myself, when she said that: is that really so different from moms here who think life-saving vaccinations cause autism?

Education, she says, is the key to survival for millions of babies in less-developed nations. UNICEF has an enthusiastic breastfeeding initiative and some more information on this issue. It’s amazing to me that “breastfeeding saves more lives than any other preventive intervention,” but it’s more amazing that this simple, cheap action isn’t already in effect.

Are you surprised to hear third-world babies aren’t getting enough breast milk?

Image via babasteve/Flickr

baby development, baby health, breastfeeding, natural parenting


To add a comment, please log in with

Use Your CafeMom Profile

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Join CafeMom or Log in to your CafeMom account. CafeMom members can keep track of their comments.

Comment As a Guest

Guest comments are moderated and will not appear immediately.

nonmember avatar ele4phant

So, this is all true and a pretty dire situation over in Africa (and other third world countries), but this is pretty old news. Formula companies have been supplying and blasting these women with marketing encouraging them to use their products for decades now.

Rose Savoie

We also have companies like Nestle to thank for the low breastfeeding rates in 3rd world countries, going in there and giving the moms "free" formula samples.

And I'm also not very happy about the comment about vaccinations, that doesn't have anything to do with the breastmilk issue, and there is no comparison between the two. 

choco... chocolat-smiles

i completely agree with the above comment. Your vaccination comment is biased and irrelevant!!

tinyp... tinypossum

The breastfeeding information is very disturbing and the vaccination comment is RIGHT ON!!!

Xakana Xakana

Yup, gotta say, you screwed it up with the vaccination comment. That's not why most non-vaccinating moms avoid them. The rest is awesome information, but it's sad that you had to throw that in there.

Danie... DanielleDes

The vax comment was right on, and the comments above just illustrate exactly what the article is talking about - it's easier to perpetuate myths than to actually educate oneself.

And if you don't vax for reasons other than the autism myth, then the comment obviously doesn't apply to you. Reading comprehension is a bitch sometimes.

nicki... nicki.hemingway

I was with you until the vax comment.  Some people don't vax because...gasp! it will make our children sick. I nearly lost one baby because of the vaccines are god mindset and I refuse to endanger my children for such nonsense, because everyone knows that it is safe to inject poison right into the blood stream of tiny babies.

nonmember avatar Megan

Perhaps the reason the women in Africa don't breastfeed has more to do with the huge AIDS epidemic than with those reasons listed above. With donations of formula and clean water breast milk is not the best in many cases.

nonmember avatar A

I was with you until you lumped in vax decisions with superstitions and ignorance. I read and research issues regarding vaccines to make an informed decision, not because someone else says to or not to. Don't be a jackass.

angev... angevil53

well, i enjoyed your vax comment...

1-10 of 34 comments 1234 Last