Follow The Stir

New Mom Secret: I Hate My Baby's Name

by Sasha Brown-Worsham on January 18, 2011 at 10:15 AM

It's hard being a new mom (or even an experienced mom to a new baby) and sometimes we do things we know we shouldn't, despite what all the experts say. But this is a safe place to share your secrets (PM me)—we'll never tell.

This Week's Secret:

My husband and I worked for months on names while I was pregnant, but we never found one we liked. We figured it would come when he was born. Well now he's here and it took us three weeks to name him. We finally did and put it on the birth certificate, and three months later, I hate it. I really feel like he has the wrong name and it's driving me crazy. If I change it, I fear I will look nuts, but if I don't, I fear I will hate my child's name forever. — Anonymous

With my first, we found the perfect name we both adored. With my second, we weren't so lucky, and to this day, the choice we made haunts me.

So, I feel your pain.

That said, your son is a baby. If you're ever going to change his name, now is the time. If you really don't like it, it doesn't make you crazy and indecisive. Names are pretty important. Give it another month or so and if it still doesn't feel right, talk to your husband and find out what he thinks. Maybe you agree and you can make the decision to change it.

Do you have any advice for this mom?



Filed Under: baby first year, mom secrets

Comments

31
  • Jenny...
    --

    JennyG0929

    January 18, 2011 at 10:28 AM

    I felt I made a mistake when we named our son, it just didn't feel right but it grew on me. Now that he is 7, I can't imagine him being named anything else.


  • Rebec...
    --

    RebeccaJill

    January 18, 2011 at 10:50 AM

    I agree that a name is very important, however, this mom sounds extremely indecisive.  Chances are that if she does go through the whole process of legally changing her son's name, then a couple of weeks or months down the road she's going to want to change it all over again because she changed her mind and no longer likes the name.  I think she should just leave well enough alone.  She already named the child.  No one forced the name on her.  Plus, what happens when the child grows up and finds out his name was changed?  How is he going to feel about that?  What if HE actually likes the first name better?


  • JessL...
    --

    JessLogansMommy

    January 18, 2011 at 10:54 AM

    I would only change it if you really feel like you can't live with it.  Perhaps a nickname or a middle name might feel better.  If you're going to change it, I would do it now to avoid confusion.  Some people might think you're nuts, but it will pass.  


  • jalaz77
    --

    jalaz77

    January 18, 2011 at 11:42 AM

    Took her 3 weeks to decide a name??? Don't change it, you will never be happy....my girls name is very common, I did not care though I have like that name for years, my middle boys name is becoming a bit more common but not even on the top 25, I won't care either way, and my last boys name is not  even on a top 50 list of names, again I don't care. I wouldn't even know any of this except people are so focused on looking to see how common my kids names are. If I like a name I will use it no matter how common or uncommon it is. Stick with what you have and move on.


  • hotic...
    --

    hoticedcoffee

    January 18, 2011 at 11:50 AM

    Oh please.  The child has a name.  She WILL seem nuts (deservedly so, IMO), if she changes the name now - he's a person, his name is a legal identity - it's not like she rescued a dog from the pound and can just call it something else.  It took her 3 weeks to come up with whatever she 'hates', the kid could be 47 before she makes a decision about a name she 'loves'.


  • momto...
    --

    momtothemax2910

    January 18, 2011 at 12:57 PM
    I did go through a brief period of "what was I thinking." In the hospital we looked at him and knew it was his name. But a few weeks later I questioned it completely - to myself - toatal what were we thinking??? But it passed - I don't know why it started or why it ended - eleven months later I wouldn't change it for the world.
  • ally
    -- Nonmember comment from

    ally

    January 18, 2011 at 1:40 PM
    change it! i liked my dd's name when i was pregnant with her, but never LOVED it - dh insisted on it (he really just wanted a decision to be made, even tho i was only 6 months along). now she is one month shy of two years old and i HATE her name. it bugs me. everyone has annoying nicknames for her that go with her name, and that bugs me too. i catch myself not even using her name, i just call her "baby girl" or "pumpkin" or some other name because i hate it THAT much. i hate that i hate it, so i try to like it, but really - it's just not her. it doesn't fit how she looks or her personality, and i catch myself at LEAST once a day, wishing i had put my foot down and waited til we found a name we BOTH loved.
  • Knitt...
    --

    KnittinMama

    January 18, 2011 at 3:53 PM
    I love my girls names. They are a perfect fit for them. I think names are important and parents should take it a bit more seriously. Im sure sweet little Airplane Walnut wont be bullied on the playground.
  • Chris...
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Christine

    January 18, 2011 at 4:11 PM
    Hard to know what to say to this mom..... my husband and I picked out a boy and a girl name for our future babies while we were still dating (it just came into discussion one night). We came up with Robyn Elizabeth for a girl and Luke William for a boy. Since I became pregnant on our engagement night on a few months after this discussion we could not wait to find out the sex of our baby. We found out we were having a Robyn Elizabeth. It not only suits her perfectly but is also a family name. Well, Robyn is a family name of sorts ~ it is the female version of my hubby's middle name, Robert. Elizabeth is my Grandma's first name, my mom's middle name, and my middle name. In fact I always knew if I had a baby girl her first or middle name would be Elizabeth. To this mom.....even though I LOVE my daughter's name I have many nicknames for her including Bitty Bear, Sweet Pie, and Little Angel. Good luck!
  • Private
    -- Nonmember comment from

    Private

    January 18, 2011 at 4:24 PM
    For the people who said some very mean comments about her being percieved as crazy and whatnot, that is just mean spirited and I hope the mom who wrote in for help doesnt let those kinds of comments bother her. If you hate the name, then change it and simply tell your friends/family that the name didnt fit and that it was a bad time in your life and that you would like to move on. Make sure that whatever name you do change it to, that you love it and are sure about it.
1-10 of 31 comments

To leave a comment, log in as a CafeMom member:

Log In

OR, use our non-member comment form: